Dr. Cory M. Marsh will present at the Ellis Foundation for Biblical Research Conference

Title: “Forgery and the Fourth Gospel: Implications of Pseudepigraphy and Authority in the Johannine Corpus”


Cory M. Marsh, PhD.


Recently, Hugo Méndez and other scholars have called into question the authenticity of the Fourth Gospel, as well as the epistles attributed to the same author. Ignoring altogether positions of single-apostolic or single-eyewitness authorship on one hand but finding untenable Johannine community theories on the other, an alternate reading views the Johannine corpus as a chain of ancient pseudepigrapha. With intent to deceive their audiences, similarities in linguistics and compositional style between John’s Gospel and his letters are best explained as a “chain of literary forgeries,” composed by multiple unknown authors masquerading as a single eyewitness. Such an assessment extends further than historical, exegetical, and theological evidence supports, revealing presuppositions that bar it from viewing John’s Gospel as genuine and authoritative. 
Therefore, this paper will critically evaluate recent arguments that the Fourth Gospel is pseudepigraphal and will discuss several implications affecting pastoral ministry. It will demonstrate that if the Fourth Gospel is a literary fake, the communicative triad of author–message–recipient becomes fictionalized, rendering useless its stated purpose that faith in its testimony yields faith in Christ resulting in eternal life (20:31). Contrarily, if it is authentic, having been produced by a historical, divinely appointed author, the Fourth Gospel carries genuine divine authority, providing not only a factual testimony through which to believe in Christ, but also an ultimately objective reason for congregational obedience to its entirety. Ultimately, the paper will offer a Johannine theology of eyewitness and authority, precluding the possibility of forgery.

Share this post

Southern California Seminary | On Campus or Online Bible Seminary


We would like to invite you to join our SCS Connect newsletter to stay up-to-date with the latest happenings on campus:

  • Free Monthly Workshops
  • Faculty Published Works
  • Available Library Resources
  • Community Involvement
  • And so much more…

We use cookies to ensure a quality experience. You can change permissions anytime on your browser. Otherwise, we assume you are content to continue.